Key takeaways
- Compare the best donut pans on cavity size, pan material, nonstick coating and donut count to bake soft, even donuts that release cleanly every batch.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. If you buy through these links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Our top pick: Wilton 6-Cavity Doughnut Baking Pan. Runner-up: Bellemain Premiere Donut Pan, 2-Pack.
A baked donut lives or dies at the moment you turn the pan over. If the rings lift out whole, with smooth sides and an even golden surface, the glaze goes on cleanly. If they tear, stick in patches, or come out pale on one side and dark on the other, no icing fixes the result. The difference is rarely the recipe. It is the pan: its material, the coating inside each cavity, the depth and diameter of the rings, and how evenly it carries heat to the batter.
This guide compares five donut pans: a simple single steel pan for a first half dozen, a two-tray steel set from Bellemain for a dozen in one load, a large twenty-cavity pan for feeding a crowd in one fill, a flexible silicone set that releases donuts with a gentle push, and a two-pack of carbon steel trays that puts a full dozen in the oven at once. Each pick is judged on cavity size and count, material, coating, and release.
What to Look For in a Donut Pan
Cavity size and donut count
Most full-size donut pans cut rings between about 3 and 3.75 inches across. That range matters because recipes are written around it. A standard recipe for twelve rings assumes cavities near 3.25 inches; fill a much wider well and the donuts spread thin, while a narrower well overflows and closes the hole. Depth matters too: a well near 0.875 inches deep gives batter room to rise into a plump ring, while shallow cavities bake flatter donuts.
Count the cavities against how you actually bake. Six cavities suit a small household. Two six-cavity pans, or one twelve- or twenty-cavity pan, suit anyone glazing for a group, because batter that waits in the bowl while a first batch bakes loses lift. For gatherings, a larger count in a single fill is worth more than any other feature here.
Pan material
Steel and aluminized steel pans hold their shape, sit flat on the rack, and brown batter where it touches the metal. Aluminized steel spreads heat especially evenly and resists rust. Carbon steel is the workhorse of two-packs: rigid, quick to heat, and dependent on its coating for release. Silicone behaves differently. It flexes, so you push each donut out from underneath instead of tipping and shaking, and it will not dent or rust. The trade-off is stability: a filled silicone pan bends, so it needs a flat baking sheet underneath when carried to the oven, and its edges brown more gently.
Nonstick coating and release
Every pan here relies on a coating or on silicone’s natural slickness for release. Traditional nonstick coatings on steel release well and wipe clean, but they wear if you cut in the pan or scrub with abrasive pads. Silicone-based coatings on some steel pans release with little greasing and no traditional nonstick layer. Pure silicone pans have no coating to wear at all; the material itself is the release surface. A light coat of baking spray, a few minutes of cooling, and a gentle twist before lifting will keep release clean batch after batch.
Oven limit and care
Check the upper temperature limit before you buy. Most donut recipes bake between 325 and 425 degrees Fahrenheit, so a pan rated to 450 degrees covers nearly everything. Care rules split along material lines: many coated steel pans tolerate a dishwasher, though hand washing keeps coatings working longer, while heavy aluminized steel is usually hand wash only. Silicone goes in the dishwasher, freezer, and microwave without complaint.
The 5 Best Donut Pans
1. Wilton 6-Cavity Doughnut Baking Pan
The Wilton 6-Cavity Doughnut Baking Pan is the straightforward first pan: one steel tray, six full-size rings, and a nonstick coating that has made it a default choice for home bakers for years. Each cavity turns out a donut about 3.75 inches across, the classic bakery ring size, so standard recipes fill it without adjustment. The steel body heats quickly, and the pan is light in the hand, which makes the flip-and-release move easy even when the tray is hot and full.
Release is this pan’s strong point. The nonstick surface lets cooled donuts drop out with a shake, and the listing rates the pan for the dishwasher, so cleanup is simple. Its 450 degree Fahrenheit oven limit covers every common baked donut recipe. Because it makes only six at a time, plan on two fills for a dozen, or pair it with a second pan.
Specs
- Cavities: 6 full-size rings per pan
- Cavity size: about 3.75 in donuts (3.25 in item diameter)
- Material: steel with a nonstick coating
- Oven safe: up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit
- Care: dishwasher safe
- Weight: 13.3 oz; model Wilton_0265632
2. Bellemain Premiere Donut Pan, 2-Pack
The Bellemain Premiere set gives you two steel trays in the box, each with six full-size molds, so a dozen donuts or bagels bake in a single oven load. Each tray measures 12.5 by 8.5 inches, a compact footprint that fits standard ovens and stacks neatly for storage. The steel body holds its shape, sits flat on the rack, and heats evenly across every cavity.
A nonstick coating does the releasing, so cooled rings lift out cleanly and the trays wipe down fast; hand washing keeps that coating working longest. Because the two trays are separate, you can bake six when that is all you need, run two flavors side by side, or fill both for a gathering. Choose this set if you want steel durability and a full dozen without one oversized tray to store.
Specs
- Set: 2 steel donut trays included
- Cavities: 6 molds per tray, 12 per full load
- Pan size: 12.5 x 8.5 in per tray
- Material: steel with a nonstick coating
- Uses: donuts and bagels
- Care: hand wash recommended
3. Wilton Perfect Results Non-Stick Donut Pan, 20-Cavity
When the goal is a lot of donuts from one fill, the Wilton Perfect Results 20-Cavity pan is in a class of its own here. A single oversized steel tray carries twenty cavities, so one gathering-size batch goes into the oven together, with no batter losing lift on the counter. The cavities are slightly smaller than the single Wilton pan above: twenty modest rings glaze quickly, cool fast, and disappear even faster at brunch.
The pan is part of Wilton’s Perfect Results line, with a durable nonstick coating over steel. It is a big tray, at about 21.5 by 15.5 inches, so measure your oven before ordering; it needs a full-size oven and a flat storage spot. The packaging includes recipe ideas for sour cream cake donuts with glazes and a cinnamon sugar topping. Choose this pan if your usual problem is quantity, not technique.
Specs
- Cavities: 20 rings in a single pan
- Cavity size: about 3.4 in diameter per cavity
- Material: steel with a durable nonstick coating
- Overall size: about 21.5 x 15.5 x 1.03 in
- Weight: 2.76 lb; model 2105-1808
- Line: Wilton Perfect Results Premium Non-Stick Bakeware
4. Walfos Silicone Donut Pan, Set of 3
The Walfos set takes the opposite approach to steel: three flexible silicone molds with no coating at all. The pans are food-grade silicone, BPA free, and release works by flexing. Let the donuts cool briefly, then push each ring up from underneath and it pops free with its surface intact, which is especially kind to soft recipes that tear when shaken out of metal. With three pans in the box, you can bake a large batch in rotation, or run different flavors side by side.
Silicone also wins on care and range. The listing describes the molds as dishwasher, microwave, and freezer safe, with heat resistance up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit, so the same pans can set chilled desserts. Two handling notes apply: set each mold on a firm baking sheet before filling, and expect slightly paler sides than steel gives, since silicone insulates rather than sears. For bakers who prize easy release and cleanup over crisp edges, this set is the most forgiving option here.
Specs
- Set: 3 silicone donut molds included
- Cavities: 6 rings per mold, 18 across the set
- Material: food-grade silicone, BPA free, no chemical coating
- Temperature range: about -40 to 500 degrees Fahrenheit
- Care: dishwasher safe; also microwave and freezer safe
- Release method: flexible push-out from underneath each cavity
5. NutriChef Nonstick Donut Pans, 2-Pack
The NutriChef 2-Pack splits the difference between the single pans and the big twenty-cavity tray: two carbon steel pans with six cavities each, so a dozen donuts bake in one oven load while each tray stays small enough to handle and store easily. Each pan measures about 12.5 by 8.5 inches, fitting compact ovens. The nonstick coating is made for clean release, and the trays are rated oven safe to 450 degrees Fahrenheit.
Carbon steel gives these pans a rigid, flat sit and quick, even heating, and the two-pack format adds flexibility the single large tray cannot match: bake six when that is all you need, or twelve when it is not. Model NCDP2LGBK is the black two-tray set, and for most households it is the most practical balance of count, size, and storage here.
Specs
- Set: 2 pans included, 12 donuts per full load
- Cavities: 6 full-size rings per pan
- Material: carbon steel with a nonstick coating
- Pan size: 12.5 x 8.5 in per tray (about 12.59 x 8.26 x 0.91 in)
- Oven safe: up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit
- Model: NCDP2LGBK
Comparison Summary
All five pans bake full-size rings, but they split clearly by count and material. The Wilton 6-Cavity (B004CYELOQ) is the simple single steel pan for a first half dozen. The Bellemain Premiere (B07N7JCS1G) pairs two steel trays for twelve donuts in one load. The Wilton Perfect Results (B01LWP6C14) makes twenty donuts in one fill and needs a full-size oven. The Walfos set (B08FHRGKW3) is the silicone option, with three flexible molds and push-out release. The NutriChef 2-Pack (B0DMTBJXPK) puts twelve carbon steel cavities in two manageable trays.
If you bake small and often, choose between the two six-cavity metal pans by heft and coating type. If you bake for groups, choose between the Wilton tray and the NutriChef pair by oven size and storage. If release and cleanup frustrate you most, choose the Walfos set and accept gentler browning.
FAQ
How full should I fill each donut cavity?
Fill each cavity about two-thirds to three-quarters full. Batter rises as it bakes, and an overfilled well spills over the center post and closes the hole, while an underfilled well gives a thin ring that dries out. A piping bag makes filling neat and keeps batter off the flat surface between cavities, where it would bake into burnt edges.
Do I still need to grease a nonstick donut pan?
A light greasing is cheap insurance, especially as a coating ages. A quick coat of baking spray or a brush of neutral oil helps delicate recipes, such as low-fat batters, that grip more than rich cake batters do. Silicone pans need the least help, but a light coat before the first use of the day still helps.
Why did my donuts stick or tear when I turned the pan?
The usual causes are turning the pan too soon, underbaking, or skipping grease. Let donuts rest in the pan for about five minutes after they leave the oven; the crumb sets as it cools, and the ring shrinks away from the cavity wall. Then invert the pan over a rack with a gentle twist. Donuts pulled out piping hot are fragile and tear.
Can I bake bagels or other recipes in a donut pan?
Yes. The ring shape suits any thick batter or soft dough that holds its form: bagel dough pressed into greased cavities, cornbread batter, baked oatmeal mixtures, and molded chilled desserts in silicone pans. Adjust the bake time, since a ring cooks faster than a muffin cup, and check doneness by spring-back and color.
Conclusion
Clean release is not luck. It comes from matching cavity size to your recipes, choosing a material that heats the way you like, and respecting the coating or silicone that does the releasing. The Wilton 6-Cavity pan is the easy first step, the Bellemain set is the durable two-tray steel option, the Wilton Perfect Results tray solves the crowd problem in one fill, the Walfos set makes release and cleanup as gentle as they get, and the NutriChef two-pack balances count and handling. Pick the pan that fits your batch size and oven, grease lightly, let rings rest before turning them out, and donuts become reliable.
More from Amazon
Programs that pair well with the guide above. Offers and eligibility are set by Amazon and may change.
Collect the home and kitchen items you want in one registry that guests can shop from.
Create a wedding registrySet up recurring deliveries of everyday items on eligible products. Terms and savings are set by Amazon.
Explore Subscribe & SaveFree shipping on eligible items, Prime Video and more. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Start a Prime free trialAudiobooks and podcasts to listen to on the go. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Try Audible freeAs an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.






Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!